Warm afternoon light falls across a walnut-and-oatmeal lounge chair beside a window overlooking a quiet Sedona desert garden in late fall.

What the Village of Oak Creek's Fall Inventory Means for Sedona Buyers

  • November 19, 2026

Bell Rock Pathway No. 96 runs 3.5 miles one way along State Route 179. It has trailheads reached through the Village of Oak Creek and views of Bell Rock and Courthouse Butte from most of its length. Drive about seven miles north on the same highway and you reach Uptown Sedona. In the first half of 2026, the price of a square foot of house changed sharply along that drive. North of it, inside the Sedona city limits, that price also moved from month to month. In the Village it hardly moved at all.

That steady figure is how to read this fall. In October, the Village of Oak Creek moved into buyer's-market territory by months of supply, after a year as the tighter of the two Sedona-area markets. The extra inventory is real. The Village's per-square-foot price held flat from January through June, though, and in October homes still closed at 99% of list. The extra supply gives buyers more homes to choose from. It is not a lower price on the homes that are priced right.

The number that stayed put

Average sale prices in this area are shaped by which homes happen to close in a given month, and in the Village of Oak Creek that can be 15 sales. Price per square foot is steadier. Through the first half of 2026 it set the two ZIP codes apart.

According to a market column in the Sedona Red Rock News, the Village's (86351) average sold price per square foot was $464 in January 2026 and $461 in June 2026. Over the same months, the City of Sedona (86336) went from $505 in January to $634 in February and back to $533 in June. An April 2026 snapshot in the paper's spring wrapup put the city at $585 per square foot, up 24% year over year, and the Village at about $456. That is roughly a 28% premium for an address inside city limits.

By June, the same comparison came to about 16%, using $533 against $461. The Village barely moved between April and June. Nearly all of the change in the gap came from Sedona proper. That is why the Village figure works as a fixed reference point when you compare the two. When someone quotes the premium for a Sedona city address, ask which month the figure comes from. In 2026 the answer moved by double digits depending on what closed north of the Village.

Why the averages kept misleading buyers

Sedona proper's numbers in June 2026 show the problem with averages. The city's average sale price fell 32.9% year over year to $911,000 that month, while its median list price rose 13.6% to $1.49 million. Sellers were asking more while the homes that actually closed were selling for less. By September 2026, the city's average had recovered to $1.30 million, up from $1.16 million in July and August, after peaking near $1.58 million in May and June.

The Village had its own version of this in October. Its average sale price fell to $869,000 that month, down 34% from the prior period, on only 15 transactions. In the Red Rock News fall update, the columnist explained that a few higher-end sales can swing a month that small. A 34% drop in a 15-sale month mostly reflects which homes closed. It does not mean Village homes got 34% cheaper. In June, the steadier median sale price was $760,000, down 6.9% year over year, while Village list prices rose about 7.7%.

The year the Village was the harder hunt

The October change matters because of how the first nine months went. The two ZIP codes started 2026 at a similar pace, with 17 Sedona sales in January against 13 in the Village. Sedona then rose to 23 sales in March, 24 in April and 33 in May before falling to 15 in June, a 42% drop from June 2025. The Village climbed into the high teens by April and stayed there through June. By midyear, Sedona had closed 168 homes and the Village 108.

Supply followed the same pattern. In June 2026, Sedona's months of supply rose to just over six, up 43% from a year earlier, as new listings grew nearly 32% and homes going under contract fell 31%. Village new listings were up 67% year over year, but buyers absorbed them almost as fast as they arrived. Months of supply rose only to 3.74. Village sales over the summer ran 83% ahead of the prior year.

Measure City of Sedona, 86336 Village of Oak Creek, 86351
Avg. sold price per sq. ft., January 2026 $505 $464
Avg. sold price per sq. ft., April 2026 $585 about $456
Avg. sold price per sq. ft., June 2026 $533 $461
Homes sold, January–June 2026 168 108
Months of supply, June 2026 just over 6 3.74
Sale-to-list ratio, June 2026 95.9% 97.3%
Latest months of supply 5.30, September 2026 7.13, October 2026
Latest sale-to-list ratio 96.7%, September 2026 99.0%, October 2026

The most recent row compares a September figure with an October figure, so it is not a perfect same-month match. Both still point the same way. The Village built up inventory after an unusually busy summer, while Sedona proper moved back to the seller side of balanced.

October's flip, read through the sale-to-list ratio

Village of Oak Creek months of supply reached 7.13 in October 2026, above the six-month line usually treated as balanced. In September 2026, the city stood at 5.30, down from 6.79 the prior period. For most of the year, the Village had been the tighter market.

The Village's sale-to-list ratio rose to 99.0% that same October. A Village buyer this fall has more homes to look at, and the listings that sit tend to be the ones priced above what the market will pay. The homes that sell, sell close to asking. Sedona proper showed the same split in midyear, when the summer column described a market where overpriced listings sit, correctly priced listings move, and the average follows whichever mix closed that month.

For a buyer weighing the two areas, the practical point is narrow. The Village's added inventory gives you more homes to choose from and more time to decide. It has not lowered the price of a well-priced home in 86351. If a Village home has sat for a while, its list price is the first thing to look at, measured against the Village's own roughly $460 per square foot from January through June 2026.

What the Village price per square foot buys

The Village's steadier per-square-foot price comes with a different setting from Sedona proper's. In the spring wrapup, the columnist attributed part of the city's premium to views, location, proximity to the best-known trails and the Sedona address. The rest came from the mix of homes that closed, since the luxury end in 86336 is far more active.

The Village's setting centers on golf and the southern red rocks. Oakcreek Country Club posts daily course conditions and runs the Oakcreek Bistro as its on-course dining. The Sedona Golf Resort course at 35 Ridge Trail Drive is a 6,646-yard, par-71 layout. Bell Rock and Courthouse Butte are the Village's landmark formations, and the Bell Rock Pathway links its trailheads along the highway.

The road matters to anyone in the Village who drives into Uptown regularly. The Arizona Department of Transportation's SR 179 pavement preservation project covers mileposts 304 to 311, from near the Red Rock Ranger Station south of the Village to Chapel Road. Work began June 17 with overnight one-lane restrictions and was expected to finish this fall.

Questions buyers are raising

How wide is the price gap between the Village of Oak Creek and Sedona proper? From January through June 2026, the Village sat near $460 per square foot while the city ranged from $505 to $634. The city's figure moves more than the Village's, so the gap you see depends on the month you measure.

Does the October inventory jump mean Village sellers are cutting prices? More supply has not yet shown up as lower prices on well-priced homes. The Village's sale-to-list ratio reached 99.0% in October 2026, in the same month its months of supply rose to 7.13. The extra inventory mostly gives buyers more homes to choose from and more time to decide.

What should a buyer make of the $869,000 October average? That figure comes from 15 closings, and a few higher-end sales can move a month that size substantially. Price per square foot over several months is a steadier guide.

If you are deciding between the Village of Oak Creek and a Sedona city address, Hague Luxury Network can walk you through how a specific list price compares with that ZIP code's 2026 figures before you make an offer. Explore our Sedona neighborhood page and buyer's guide, or Request a Confidential Consultation to talk through the homes on your shortlist.

Hague Luxury Network secondary

About the Author - Hague Luxury Network

At Hague Luxury Network, powered by 72SOLD Luxury division, we dedicate ourselves to delivering unparalleled service, expertise, and results for luxury home sellers. Join us in redefining luxury real estate, your extraordinary property deserves nothing less.

. 

Hague Luxury Network

Read More Articles

Work With Us

We specialize in identifying every potential buyer for your home before it ever hits the market.

Follow Me on Instagram